Our Menu
A Menu Made
with Magic
Everything is baked fresh each morning — a simple, seasonal selection of handcrafted treats made to delight.
Pickup orders only · Baked fresh daily
Special Cupcakes
Tandy Cake
A vanilla cupcake filled with peanut butter topped with chocolate drizzled with peanut butter.
Contains: gluten, dairy, eggs
Little Red's Velvet Secret✦ Featured
A red velvet cupcake frosted with a swirling canopy of vanilla buttercream. Take a bite to discover a velvety white chocolate ganache center.
Contains: gluten, dairy, eggs
Birthday Cake (Cupcake)
Funfetti cupcake filled with white chocolate ganache, topped with blue buttercream and sprinkles.
Contains: gluten, dairy, eggs
Gingerbread Cupcake✦ Featured
A gingerbread cupcake filled with molasses ganache topped with vanilla buttercream and gingerbread.
Contains: gluten, dairy, eggs
Creamsicle
A soft vanilla cupcake filled with orange flavored white chocolate ganache, topped with swirled vanilla and orange buttercream.
Contains: gluten, dairy, eggs
Creamsicle (Gluten Free)
A soft vanilla cupcake filled with orange flavored white chocolate ganache, topped with swirled vanilla and orange buttercream. This product made in a bakery that also uses gluten
Contains: dairy, eggs
Andes Mint✦ Featured
Rich chocolate cupcake filled with mint ganache or chocolate mint cream, topped with mint buttercream and an Andes mint.
Contains: gluten, dairy, eggs
Nutella Strawberry✦ Featured
A vanilla cupcake filled with fresh strawberries, topped with Nutella frosting and a fresh strawberry.
Contains: gluten, dairy, eggs
Nutella Strawberry (Gluten-Free)
A vanilla cupcake filled with fresh strawberries, topped with Nutella frosting and a fresh strawberry. (This product is baked in a facility which also uses gluten)
Contains: dairy, eggs
Pumpkin Roll
A pumpkin spice cupcake filled and topped with cream cheese frosting.
Contains: gluten, dairy, eggs
Mocha Latte Cupcake
A chocolate cupcake filled with chocolate espresso ganache topped with buttercream
Contains: gluten, dairy, eggs
Classic Cupcakes
Pixie Dust Party
A golden vanilla cupcake filled with velvety white ganache, topped with vanilla buttercream, and showered in rainbow sprinkles.
Contains: gluten, dairy, eggs
Pixie Dust Party (Gluten Free)✦ Featured
A fluffy vanilla cupcake filled with velvety white ganache, topped with vanilla buttercream and showered in tropical beach sprinkles. (This product produced in a bakery which uses gluten)
Contains: dairy, eggs
The Dark Dragon's Hoard
Venture deep into a rich chocolate cave to discover a hidden treasure trove of peanut butter, topped with a golden peanut butter buttercream, and a decadent crown jewel.
Contains: gluten, eggs, dairy
The Dark Dragon's Hoard (Gluten Free)
Rich chocolate cupcake with a peanut butter center, topped with fluffy peanut butter frosting and a mini Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup. (Baked in a bakery that uses gluten)
Contains: dairy, eggs, nuts
The Dark Forest
Get lost in a delicious mystery. This intense chocolate cake is filled with a rich, velvety ganache and topped with a thick canopy of chocolate ganache buttercream.
Contains: gluten, dairy, eggs
The Dark Forest (Gluten Free)
Rich chocolate cupcake filled with chocolate ganache, topped with a chocolate ganache frosting and chocolate sprinkles. (Baked in a bakery that uses gluten)
Contains: dairy, eggs
Cookies
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Contains: gluten, dairy, eggs
Sugar Cookies
Contains: gluten, dairy, eggs
Cakes
Traditional Cheesecake
Contains: gluten, dairy, eggs
Strawberry Cheesecake
Contains: gluten, dairy, eggs
Miscellaneous
Chocolate Ganache Covered Brownie
Contains: gluten, dairy, eggs
Gluten Free Brownie
(This product produced in a bakery which uses gluten)
Contains: dairy, eggs
Scone (Custom Orders)
If you would like a particular type of scone, tell us what type and how many and we can make some for you.
Scone (Daily Flavors)
Scones are baked daily, see our social media @once_upon_a_whisk_milton for updates. If you are placing an order, please enter the flavor you would like below. We usually have traditional and blueberry.
Contains: gluten, dairy, eggs
Pies!!
Fairy Godmother's Pumpkin Pie✦ Featured
The quintessential holiday classic, smooth and perfectly spiced to transform your desert table.
Contains: gluten, dairy, eggs
The Cobbler’s Wet Bottom Shoofly✦ Featured
A deep, rich molasses classic with a perfectly gooey bottom and a sweet, spiced crumb topping.
Contains: gluten, dairy, eggs
Snow White’s Classic Apple✦ Featured
Traditional spiced apple filling baked inside a golden, flaky pastry crust.
Contains: gluten, dairy, eggs
Golden Goose Caramel Apple Crumb✦ Featured
Spiced autumn apples drizzled with rich caramel and piled high with a buttery streusel crumb.
Contains: gluten, dairy, eggs
Menu items and availability may vary daily based on fresh ingredients. Please notify us of any additional dietary needs when ordering.
Ready to place your order?
Choose your favourites and we'll have them freshly baked and waiting for you.
Place an Order