Our Story
A little bakery with
a lot of heart
Once Upon a Whisk was built on one simple belief — that a really good cupcake can make any moment feel like the beginning of something wonderful.
Our Store
At home in Milton
We are a small, independently owned bakery on Front Street. Our space is cozy, our counter is always stocked, and there is almost certainly something warm coming out of the oven when you walk in.
- 54 S Front Street, Milton PA 17847
- (570) 437-3736
Our Team
The people behind the magic
Shelly Craig
Owner
Hannah Craig
Assistant Manager
Skye Anthony
Lead Baker
Jillian Carson
Baker
Lydia Frank
Customer Service Associate
Katelyn Miller
Customer Service Associate
Our Mission
What we stand for
We didn't open a bakery to be just another cupcake shop. We opened one to give people a reason to pause, celebrate the small things, and eat something genuinely delicious.
Something New, Every Week
We strive to bring new and exciting recipes to the counter for your enjoyment. Stop by every week to see our latest creations.
Handmade with Care
Every single cupcake is decorated by hand. We bake in small batches daily so you always get something that was made with intention.
Joy in Every Bite
We believe sweets should feel a little magical. Whether it's your birthday, a Tuesday, or a rainy afternoon — there's always a reason.
Ready to taste the story?
Order fresh cupcakes for pickup — choose your favourites and we'll have them ready.
Order NowAre you part of the team? Team member login