A Menu Made
with Magic

Nutter Butter✦ Featured

A peanut butter cupcake filled with a creamy Nutter Butter infused peanut butter center, topped with peanut butter frosting and a mini Nutter Butter cookie.

Contains: gluten, dairy, eggs, nuts

Cookie Butter✦ Featured

A cookie butter filled vanilla cupcake topped with cookie buttercream and a Biscoff cookie.

Contains: gluten, dairy, eggs

Cookie Monster

A blue Funfetti cupcake filled with edible cookie dough, topped with blue buttercream and a mini Chips Ahoy cookie.

Contains: gluten, dairy, eggs

Thin mint✦ Featured

A chocolate cupcake filled with mint chocolate ganache, topped with mint buttercream and a chocolate mint cookie

Contains: gluten, dairy, eggs

Pumpkin Chocolate Chip

A pumpkin spice cupcake infused with mini chocolate chips, filled with chocolate ganache and topped with cream cheese frosting, topped off with pumpkin spice sanding sugar, and a mini chocolate chips.

Contains: gluten, dairy, eggs

Animal Cracker

A vanilla cupcake filled with chocolate ganache, topped with buttercream, sprinkles and a chocolate covered animal cracker

Contains: gluten, dairy, eggs

Pixie Dust Party✦ Featured

A golden vanilla cupcake filled with velvety white ganache, topped with vanilla buttercream, and showered in rainbow sprinkles.

Contains: gluten, dairy, eggs

Pixie Dust Party (Gluten Free)

A fluffy vanilla cupcake filled with velvety white ganache, topped with vanilla buttercream and showered in tropical beach sprinkles. (This product produced in a bakery which uses gluten)

Contains: dairy, eggs

The Dark Dragon's Hoard✦ Featured

Venture deep into a rich chocolate cave to discover a hidden treasure trove of peanut butter, topped with a golden peanut butter buttercream, and a decadent crown jewel.

Contains: gluten, eggs, dairy

The Dark Dragon's Hoard (Gluten Free)

Rich chocolate cupcake with a peanut butter center, topped with fluffy peanut butter frosting and a mini Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup. (Baked in a bakery that uses gluten)

Contains: dairy, eggs, nuts

The Dark Forest

Get lost in a delicious mystery. This intense chocolate cake is filled with a rich, velvety ganache and topped with a thick canopy of chocolate ganache buttercream.

Contains: gluten, dairy, eggs

The Dark Forest (Gluten Free)

Rich chocolate cupcake filled with chocolate ganache, topped with a chocolate ganache frosting and chocolate sprinkles. (Baked in a bakery that uses gluten)

Contains: dairy, eggs

Hansel and Gretel's Breadcrumbs

A golden vanilla cupcake packed with edible chocolate chip cookie dough, topped with vanilla buttercream and a cookie dough center.

Contains: gluten, dairy, eggs

Midnight Mirror

A chocolate cake hiding a creamy vanilla center, topped with a cloud of Oreo buttercream and a mini Oreo.

Contains: gluten, dairy, eggs

Midnight Mirror (Gluten Free)✦ Featured

A chocolate cupcake filled with Oreo buttercream topped with Oreo infused buttercream and a mini Oreo cookie. (This product baked in a facility that also uses gluten)

Contains: dairy, eggs

Chocolate Chip Cookie

Contains: gluten, dairy, eggs

Sugar Cookies

Contains: gluten, dairy, eggs

Traditional Cheesecake

Contains: gluten, dairy, eggs

Strawberry Cheesecake

Contains: gluten, dairy, eggs

Chocolate Ganache Covered Brownie

Contains: gluten, dairy, eggs

Gluten Free Brownie

(This product produced in a bakery which uses gluten)

Contains: dairy, eggs

Scone (Custom Orders)

If you would like a particular type of scone, tell us what type and how many and we can make some for you.

Scone (Daily Flavors)

Scones are baked daily, see our social media @once_upon_a_whisk_milton for updates. If you are placing an order, please enter the flavor you would like below. We usually have traditional and blueberry.

Contains: gluten, dairy, eggs